Pension Rights Display Picture

Pension Rights

CalPERS or the State of California's Public Employees Retirement System provides retirement benefits to numerous state and local government employees. The California State Teachers' Retirement System or CalSTRS provides retirement, disability and survivor benefits for full-time and part-time California public school educators. Many other government pension programs exist that are largely built upon the same foundational principles and incorporate the same body of law.

Attorneys at MARTIN & VANEGAS, APC represent CalPERS and CalSTRS members in administrative appeals and hearings and, if necessary, writs of mandate to dispute determinations which have reduced or eliminated entitlement to these benefits.

From the removal of service credits from members accounts to determinations that final compensation does not meet CalPERS rules, attorneys at MARTIN & VANEGAS, APC utilize provisions of the Government Code, prior administrative decisions, and case law to submit comprehensive appeals to CalPERS and CalSTRS and assist our clients in putting their best case forward at the administrative hearing about their government pension benefits. 

ERISA, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, is a Federal law which governs many employee welfare benefit plans including pensions, health insurance, and disability policies. Those plans which are not covered by ERISA are typically individual policies or policies issued to employees of governmental entities. If a benefit plan is not covered by ERISA, a beneficiary can sue the plan for bad faith insurance practices and other state law causes of action. If, however, you work for a private employer and you receive benefits through a group policy, your plan is likely subject to ERISA.

In the event that an ERISA beneficiary is denied pension benefits, coverage for medical expenses, or disability benefits under a plan governed by ERISA, the beneficiary can only sue the plan after exhausting any available administrative remedies. This means the beneficiary must submit internal appeals of any denial of benefits with the Plan Administrator as required by the Plan's documents and await a final decision before suing in Court. This also means the beneficiary can only sue in Federal Court and cannot allege state law causes of action against the plan, nor obtain bad faith damages, emotional distress damages, nor punitive damages. In an action for denial of benefits from an ERISA plan, the beneficiary can only obtain the benefits owed and attorneys fees. The evidence in an ERISA case in Federal Court will often be limited to the beneficiary's claims file which has been maintained by the insurer or Plan Administrator.

ERISA Administrative Appeals: A Key Step in the Process

Because ERISA severely restricts the type of damages a beneficiary can obtain in litigation, it is wise for a beneficiary to treat internal appeals with the Plan seriously. A beneficiary should submit all supporting documentation and all supporting legal arguments to the Plan during the administrative appeals process in order to create the best record possible in the event that litigation is necessary. Our law offices have a breadth of experience in filing administrative appeals in cases where health insurance companies have denied coverage for certain medical expenses and where insurers have denied short-term or long-term disability benefits to their insureds. Attorneys at MARTIN & VANEGAS, APC gather and review medical records, obtain assessments and reports from treating physicians and psychiatrists, and author persuasive appeals citing relevant federal case law.

ERISA Litigation

Attorneys at MARTIN & VANEGAS, APC have filed complaints alleging ERISA violations in Federal Court and understand well both the limitations and possibilities in obtaining denied benefits under ERISA. Please contact us to set an appointment for a free initial consultation about your ERISA questions. We can sometimes offer a flat rate to review your claims file and medical documents to better advise you about the possibilities of winning an administrative appeal or ERISA lawsuit.

COBRA Remedies

COBRA, the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act, amended ERISA and gives a remedy to workers whose health insurance is terminated without required notification and without the option to continue to pay for benefits under their employer's group health insurance plan. If an employee suffers a qualifying event, including a termination or significant reduction in hours, the employer must give the employee notice that they will lose their health insurance benefits. The employee can then elect to continue paying for coverage under the employer's plan. The State of California has its own version of COBRA (Cal-COBRA) which provides additional protections and may cover employees if their employer, due to its small size, is not subject to the Federal COBRA law. A violation of COBRA may subject an employer to liability for penalties as well as the costs of medical care the employee required while uninsured.